Overall I rate The Social Reckoning movie a 5.5/10. I watched this movie in theaters in October 2026.
The good parts
I think the movie accomplished its goal of showing what placing profit over people looks like. The guy who played Zuck did a very solid job insofar as I really disliked Zuck notably more by the end of the movie. The “head of public relations” guy also did a good job. I doubt that such a person actually said something to the effect of Facebook being “post government” (I forget the exact phrasing) but I 100% buy that executives and most employees of the titan tech companies truly believe that. The movie did a good job of showing how much of peoples’ experiences online and especially on Facebook/social media are driven by choices. We construct online spaces and we can construct them in ways that maximize profit while preying on whomever enters the lair of the profiteers, or we can construct them in ways that benefit the most people.
I especially enjoyed the scene during the January 6th insurrection where Zuck “goes nonverbal” when asked whether Facebook will remove/shadowban posts that encouraged insurrection, including those from Trump. It was quite funny.
Victims
It seems as though the necessary condition for reform is harm towards white women. The first scene of the movie depicts an inebriated white woman hurling racial epithets at black and latina cops. But she is the victim. The other “victim with a face” was a white teenage girl suffering from online bullying. Indeed Facebook preyed on both of them. However, their plight pales in comparison to those of south asian and african peoples.
“I was like an animal that was being traded by one owner to another,” said the woman, who spoke from Kuwait on condition of anonymity out of fear of reprisals. “If Facebook and Instagram won’t take stronger steps against this anomaly, there will be more victims like me. I was lucky because I did not end up dead or a sexual slave.” PBS
But Facebook’s role in human traficking receives nothing more than a passing reference in the movie. Clearly Bill Burr’s monologue is more important.
This white woman in the first scene of the movie tumbled down the “alt”-right racist facebook rabbit hole and was an old friend of the main character. Indeed the main character’s wikipedia page mentions that the “radicaliation” of her friend instigated her change in attitude towards Facebook and its role on the public. If indeed her job involved understanding the effects of Facebook and some degree of “advocacy” for users, then clearly to her, some victims matter more than others. Leftists always make fun of many people for having no empathy – for only seeing some issue when it personally affects them or their personal circle. I couldn’t help but feel that disdain for the main character.
One may retort that “Sorkin just made the movie he wanted – if you want a different movie, make one.” To which I would respond: what does this movie want to be about? Does it want to describe the “facebook papers” “revelations” about the January 6th insurrection? Does it want to be about the broader effects of social media on Americans? Or does it really want to get to the heart of the matter that extends far beyond the USA? If it just wants to dramatize the “facebook papers” “revelations” then it did a relatively poor job because it pulled its punches – unless you believe that the effects on Americans are more important than the effects on everyone else in the world (which most Americans believe). If it wants to really drill into the rot that afflicts many of the social media companies, then it fell well short.
The Core Critique
All pieces of the “Sorkin cinematic universe” that I have seen – The Social
Network, The Social Reckoning, and The Newsroom truly loves glorifying
journalists…who seek to reform the worst excesses of capitalism without
changing its fundamental structures. I rolled my eyes when the woman who played
the Wall Street Journal editor said something to the effect of “Of course I’m
all for capitalism – I’m literally an editor for the Wall Street Journal – but
this needs to be regulated.” Classic liberal move. I don’t think Sorkin meant to
criticize that sentiment at all. She was portrayed as some kind of
“centrist”/“moderate”/“pragmatist.” In that line, I basically heard “of course
civilizational rape of the Congo to extract cheap cobalt for twinkies smart
phones in the metropole is good and righteous but we need regulation so it
doesn’t backfire on white women.” Maybe this is cynical, but I think most people
are not nearly cynical enough.